Check If You Qualify

Why a Debt Arrangement Scheme is better than a Debt Management Plan?

Sharon McDougall - Updated - 2nd May 2024 - 5 minutes to read

If you’re struggling to repay debt and looking for a way to better manage the situation, you may have come across two commonly-offered options. Both involve repaying all the money you owe rather than writing off a proportion of the debt after the end of the agreement, but one is backed by the Scottish government.

The Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS) is a debt solution unique to Scotland. It lowers your monthly repayments to an affordable level, and is legally-binding for you and your creditors although there is some flexibility built-in.

The other option, a Debt Management Plan (DMP), has a similar structure to DAS but it is an informal arrangement.

DAS and DMP

When you have several credit cards and store cards at their maximum limit and you’re only making the minimum payments each month, additional interest and late-payment charges can quickly make your situation untenable.

Add to that any personal loans you’ve taken out, plus arrears of council tax and household utility bills, and you have a debt situation that’s difficult to escape. Both the Debt Arrangement Scheme and Debt Management Plan are designed to help you repay unsecured debt, so what makes the Debt Arrangement Scheme a better option?

An official debt management solution

DAS is an official, government-backed scheme that helps people with a regular income and who are in debt, to repay what they owe over a longer period of time. An approved money advisor works with you to formulate a Debt Payment Plan (DPP), and this is presented to your creditors for approval.

A Debt Management Plan, on the other hand, is arranged and administered by a representative of a debt advisory organisation, and is an informal arrangement with creditors to repay the debt in full.

Its unofficial nature introduces a range of issues that could hamper your attempts to escape debt. These include:

Scotland Debt Calculator

Get a rough indication of what your repayments might be under each of our different debt solutions.

Your Total Debt

£0 - £5,000

£5,000 - £10,000

£10,000 - £20,000

£20,000+

Your Employment Status

I am employed

I am self-employed

I am unemployed

I am a student

I am retired

Your Total Monthly Income

£0 - £1,000

£1,000 - £2,000

£2,000 - £3,000

£3,000+

What can you pay monthly towards your debt?

£0 - £100

£100 - £200

£200 - £300

£300+

Protection from creditor legal action

The fact that DAS offers you legal protection from creditor action is one of its main advantages. You’re protected from any legal action whilst the arrangement is in place, as long as you comply with all the terms and conditions.

As far as a Debt Management Plan is concerned, although it isn’t necessarily in your creditors’ interests to take legal action against you, there is nothing to prevent them from taking you to court even if you fully adhere to the agreement throughout its term.

Built-in flexibility

A downward turn in your circumstances, such as job loss or long-term illness, could trigger legal action by one or more of your creditors, but DAS is structured in such a way as to protect your interests.

If you did lose your job, your money advisor would renegotiate the terms of your agreement to account for the loss of, or drop in, income. You may even be able to take a payment break of up to six months.

With a DMP, your creditors are able to demand changes whenever they choose as it is not protected by law – this can easily derail your long-term financial plans.

Freezing interest and charges on your debt

One of the overriding benefits of the Debt Arrangement Scheme is that creditors must stop adding interest and charges to your debt once it is in place. Additional interest and fees on top of an already burgeoning debt problem can be the tipping point for many people, forcing them into insolvency and a more complex path to escape a stressful situation.

If you take out a DMP, you’ll probably find that most of your creditors will agree to freeze the interest, but they are not prevented from doing this by law. In theory, they could decide to apply interest and charges on their debt at any time, and some may even do so from the start.

Communications with creditors

Having to communicate with creditors can be extremely stressful, and many people in debt live in fear of the next phone call. The Debt Arrangement Scheme allows you to step back and let your money advisor deal with creditors, so you can focus on improving your financial future without the additional stress.

A Debt Management Plan doesn’t incorporate this valuable aspect, leaving you open to creditor contact and potential harassment in the form of letters, emails and phone calls.

Protection for your most valuable assets

As long as you continue to make the agreed payments in full and on time, valuable assets such as your home and car will be protected by the Debt Arrangement Scheme.

Under a DMP, creditors could take action involving your property, such as an inhibition order. This ‘attaches’ the debt to your home so that you wouldn’t be able to sell it or remortgage without repaying your debt from the proceeds.

A fixed-term arrangement

If you decide to use the Debt Arrangement Scheme you’ll know exactly when it finishes, and for personal debts it can last for up to ten years. This is both motivating and encouraging as you’re able to see an end to your financial troubles, and plan further ahead for the future.

A DMP has no fixed end-point, and in theory could continue for decades. Your creditors may decide to add interest and other charges to the amount owed at any point during the arrangement, leaving you exposed to a seemingly endless period of repayments.

Being government-backed, the Debt Arrangement Scheme is structured in such a way that it helps you repay unsecured debt without the worry of creditor legal action. It is a better option that works in your interests, providing the security and flexibility you need to recover from serious financial problems.

If you would like to know more about the Debt Arrangement Scheme and how it would work for you in practice, or indeed any other debt solution in Scotland, call our expert team to arrange an initial meeting free-of-charge. Scotland Debt Solutions has been helping Scottish residents out of debt since 1989, and operates from five offices around Scotland.

facebook colour icon twitter colour icon linkedin colour icon messenger colour icon whatsapp colour icon email colour icon
Sharon McDougall Square

Sharon McDougall

Manager

Other Articles

Can I borrow money whilst I’m in a Trust Deed? Can I Borrow Money

Can I borrow money whilst I’m in a Trust Deed?

Borrowing money when you’re already deeply in debt requires careful consideration, and consultation with your trustee, as there are various factors associated with further borrowing in this situatio...

Your guide to getting a mortgage after a Trust Deed Guide to get a mortgage

Your guide to getting a mortgage after a Trust Deed

If you’re about to be discharged from a Trust Deed, you may be wondering to what extent your ability to obtain a mortgage has been affected.

What is an inhibition court order in Scotland? Court Order

What is an inhibition court order in Scotland?

If you’ve lost your job, state benefits and tax credits can provide vital financial support to see you through this tough time and help you avoid taking on too much debt while you look for more work...

About

Why Choose Us

Usp Discussion

Speak Direct With

A Qualified Adviser

Headset

We Don't Operate

Call Centres

Usp Location

5 Offices in Scotland

National Coverage

Usp House

Ask us About

Home Visits

Usp Award

Fully Regulated Advisors

From a Reputable Firm

Usp Hand Heart

Helping Scots Get

Out of Debt Since 1989

We'll give you a call

Our Scottish based team can help advise you on your debt problems.

Here at Scotland Debt Solutions we take your privacy seriously and will only use your personal information to contact you with regards to your enquiry. We will not use your information for marketing purposes. See our Privacy Policy.

Tools

Useful Tools

Personalised Debt Report
Usp Planner

Personalised Debt Report

Our personalised debt report will help you better understand your financial position and see where your money is going.

Debt Report
Instant Scheduled Call & WhatsApp
Headset

Instant Scheduled Call & WhatsApp

Arrange a call with an expert advisor at a time to suit you or contact our team via WhatsApp for immediate help and advice.

Arrange Callback
Find a Local Office
Usp Signpost

Find a Local Office

We have five offices located across Scotland. Find your nearest one here.

Find an Office

OUR SERVICES

We can help you with...

Sequestration

Sequestration

Sequestration is the Scottish version of bankruptcy and may be suitable for you if you do not have the money to pay back your debts

Find out More
Trust Deeds in Scotland

Trust Deeds in Scotland

A Trust Deed involves making a monthly contribution to your debts for up to four years. After this time any remaining debt included in the Trust Deed will not need to be paid.

Find out More
Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS)

Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS)

A Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS) lets you pay off your debt through a series of manageable instalments over a reasonable length of time.

Find out More
Business Debts
Icon Briefcase

Business Debts

Whether you are a sole trader or a limited company director, we can help you work through your current financial problems including money owed to HMRC

Business Debts

Our Insolvency Practitioners are regulated by ICAS or the IPA and our firm is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority

Fees and Information: There are fees associated with our services. These will be fully explained before entering into any of the personal debt solutions referred to on this website. Full details of our fees and how these are charged are fully explained to you prior to you committing to any particular service.

ICAS Insolvency Practitioners