Debt report banner

How has the Mond ruling changed PPI claims after a Trust Deed?

Free Debt Report

Reviewed 23rd December 2021

If you are a Scottish resident in financial difficulty, you may have entered into a Trust Deed in order to restructure debt repayments to creditors. A Trust Deed is a fixed voluntary agreement made between the debtor and creditor, with the help of a trustee. Debt is broken down into smaller, affordable instalments, typically lasting up to four years. A Trust Deed can be used for debts in excess of £5,000, but if the scale of the debts is significantly larger, you may have to consider a Debt Arrangement Scheme. By taking out a trust deed with Scotland Debt Solutions, all phone calls and letters from those you owe money to will stop and instead all communication will be go through us.

Prior to the Mond ruling, the manner in which PPI compensation was distributed amongst parties differed. If an individual discharged from a Trust Deed received payment from a successful PPI claim after the final distribution had been made, the funds would be allocated to the creditor. This would occur even if the Trust Deed had been discharged.

The recent Mond ruling now protects debtors as they will be able to retain PPI payment and assets after a Trust Deed has been discharged.

Dooneen Vs Mond

The Supreme Court recently issued a judgment in the appeal case of Dooneen Ltd (t/a McGinness Associates) and another v Mond. The debtor in the case was Dooneen Ltd and the appellant was Mr Mond who disputed entitlement of PPI compensation after final distribution.

The dispute in question was whether the debtor was entitled to the PPI compensation after the Trust Deed had been discharged and final distribution was made. The appellant argued that the final distribution had not been made as the assets of the debtor were not exhausted, nor was the creditor paid in full. As a result, the appellant argued that the PPI compensation should be distributed to the creditor.

As the existence of the PPI claim was not apparent at the time of final distribution, nor was the compensation deliberately concealed, Lord Reed and four other justices ruled in favour of Dooneen Ltd. As a result, the debtor was able to retain the PPI payment.

The judge also said that proper clarity should always be exercised when a final distribution is made by the creditor to avoid consequences as such and to eliminate ambiguity around the status of the Trust Deed, including the discharge date of the Trust Deed.

The full Supreme Court judgment can be found here.

This Supreme Court judgment clarifies uncertainties deriving from previous cases. It establishes that the creditor is not entitled to assets which are discovered after the final distribution has been made in relation to the Trust Deed, or after a Trust Deed has been discharged.

If you have any questions on how a Trust Deed works, please get in touch with the Scotland Debt team. We have been helping Scottish residents with debt problems since 1989, including sequestration and insolvency. Our debt experts can guide you through the process and help determine the best options. Please contact one our team members to arrange a free same-day consultation at any of our four offices in Scotland, or a location of your choice.

Debt Report
Debt Report

Get your FREE Debt Report today

Find out which debt solution is best for you

Our debt report is completely free to use and is a great starting point for anyone with over £5000 of debts looking to take control of their debt issues. By providing us with details of your incomings and outgoings we can suggest the most appropriate way forward for you.

Get Your Report

FAQ on Trust Deeds

Do I have to get my creditors to agree to my trust deed?

Applying for a trust deed has been on my mind for some time but I’m concerned that all creditors may not agree to my trust deed? What if one of them doesn’t agree?

How does entering a Trust Deed affect your credit rating?

Yes, although a Trust Deed is not a court process the creditors you have made defaults with are likely to notify the credit reference agencies that you have missed payments. There will be an entry on the Register of Insolvencies that you are subject to a Trust Deed.

How long does it take to set up a trust deed?

A Trust Deed can be setup very quickly. Once you have discussed your financial situation in full with an Advisor and taken time to consider that this is the most appropriate option taking all factors into account. The Trust Deed document and accompanying paperwork can be signed which then gives the Trustee the relevant powers to act on your behalf. The Trustee will make contact with all your creditors and from that point you can stop making payments to the individual creditors and pass all correspondence for the Trustee to deal with. Thus relieving you from the pressure instantaneously.

What are the consequences of not keeping up payments of a trust deed?

The Trustee will write to you every six months throughout the period of your Trust Deed to monitor and assess your Financial Position and your ability to maintain the contribution at the current level.

What are the set-up costs of a Trust Deed?

There are no initial setup or additional hidden costs in a trust deed. The Trustee’s fee’s and outlays for administering your trust deed are met from the contributions you pay in on a monthly basis or/and from the assets which may have to be realised in your Trust Deed. The Trustee is paid prior to making a distribution to your creditors. The Trustee’s fees are broken down into three categories, fixed fee, percentage of realisations and costs and expenses associated with the Trust Deed.

What does a protected trust deed mean?

A protected Trust Deed is binding on your creditors. It means that if you comply with the terms of your trust deed then the creditors cannot take any further action against you to recover any debts you might be due to them. They cannot arrest your earnings or petition for your sequestration whilst you are subject to a Protected Trust Deed. Unlike an ordinary Trust Deed which is not binding on your creditors. If when presented with your Trust Deed Proposals more than half in number or one third in value of creditors object to your Trust Deed then it will fail to reach protected status.

What would the consequences be if I missed a trust deed payment despite my circumstances clearly changing?

The Trustee will write to you every six months throughout the period of your Trust Deed to monitor and assess your Financial Position and your ability to maintain the contribution at the current level. In addition to this the Trustee will explain at the outset of the Trust Deed that should you have any change in circumstance which will affect your ability to make a contribution you must update him with immediate effect. If you have a change in circumstance and notify the Trustee of this providing evidence to substantiate your change in circumstance. The Trustee will take all factors into account before making a decision as to whether to reduce, suspend, stop or infact increase your contribution. It may be depending on the circumstance that your Trust Deed period is extended or shortened or that you are able to suspend the payments until such time as your Income position improves.

Whats the difference between an IVA and a Trust Deed

The main differences between and IVA and Trust Deed are that one is an English Debt Relief process and the other is a Scottish debt relief process. An IVA can only be accessed by English and Welsh residents whereas Trust Deeds are only available for Scottish Residents. In an IVA you must have minimum unsecured debts of £15,000 whereas a Trust Deed is a minimum of £5000. The duration is also slightly different in that an IVA generally lasts for sixty months whereas a Trust Deed lasts for forty eight months.

Will all my debts be covered by the terms of a Trust Deed?

I am a single mother of two children with a number of debts and loans, including some spiralling payday loans that are stressing me out. I have looked into debt management plans and trust deeds and it seems as though the trust deed is the best option but I’m not sure whether I can consolidate all my debts into one monthly payment? Can loans be included in this?


Our Other Services

Business Debts

Business Debts

Whether you are a sole trader or a limited company director, we can help you work through your current financial problems including money owed to HMRC

Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS)

Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS)

A Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS) lets you pay off your debt through a series of manageable instalments over a reasonable length of time.



Sequestration is the Scottish version of bankruptcy and may be suitable for you if you do not have the money to pay back your debts

We'll give you a call

Our Scottish based team can help advise you on your debt problems.

Here at Scotland Debt Solutions we take your privacy seriously and will only use your personal information to contact you with regards to your enquiry. We will not use your information for marketing purposes. See our Privacy Policy.
The team

Meet our qualified Scottish based team

100% Confidential advice

Book an appointment

Useful Tools

Personalised Debt Report

Personalised Debt Report

Our personalised debt report will help you better understand your financial position and see where your money is going.

Free Scheduled Call

Free Scheduled Call

 Arrange a call with an expert advisor at a time to suit you.

Find a Local Office

Find a Local Office

We have five offices located across Scotland. Find your nearest one here.

Close Menu Share with a Friend

Send this page to a friend

via Whatsapp via Messenger via Messenger via Email
Make sure you have WhatsApp installed.

Copy link to clipboard

This site uses cookies to monitor site performance and provide a more responsive and personalised experience. You must agree to our use of certain cookies. For more information on how we use and manage cookies please read our PRIVACY POLICY