How has the Mond ruling changed PPI claims after a Trust Deed?
February 26, 2019
If you are a Scottish resident in financial difficulty, you may have entered into a Trust Deed in order to restructure debt repayments to creditors. A Trust Deed is a fixed voluntary agreement made between the debtor and creditor, with the help of a trustee. Debt is broken down into smaller, affordable instalments, typically lasting up to four years. A Trust Deed can be used for debts in excess of £5,000, but if the scale of the debts is significantly larger, you may have to consider a Debt Arrangement Scheme.
Prior to the Mond ruling, the manner in which PPI compensation was distributed amongst parties differed. If an individual discharged from a Trust Deed received payment from a successful PPI claim after the final distribution had been made, the funds would be allocated to the creditor. This would occur even if the Trust Deed had been discharged.
The recent Mond ruling now protects debtors as they will be able to retain PPI payment and assets after a Trust Deed has been discharged.
Dooneen Vs Mond
The Supreme Court recently issued a judgment in the appeal case of Dooneen Ltd (t/a McGinness Associates) and another v Mond. The debtor in the case was Dooneen Ltd and the appellant was Mr Mond who disputed entitlement of PPI compensation after final distribution.
The dispute in question was whether the debtor was entitled to the PPI compensation after the Trust Deed had been discharged and final distribution was made. The appellant argued that the final distribution had not been made as the assets of the debtor were not exhausted, nor was the creditor paid in full. As a result, the appellant argued that the PPI compensation should be distributed to the creditor.
As the existence of the PPI claim was not apparent at the time of final distribution, nor was the compensation deliberately concealed, Lord Reed and four other justices ruled in favour of Dooneen Ltd. As a result, the debtor was able to retain the PPI payment.
The judge also said that proper clarity should always be exercised when a final distribution is made by the creditor to avoid consequences as such and to eliminate ambiguity around the status of the Trust Deed, including the discharge date of the Trust Deed.
The full Supreme Court judgment can be found here.
This Supreme Court judgment clarifies uncertainties deriving from previous cases. It establishes that the creditor is not entitled to assets which are discovered after the final distribution has been made in relation to the Trust Deed, or after a Trust Deed has been discharged.
If you have any questions on how a Trust Deed works, please get in touch with the Scotland Debt team. We have been helping Scottish residents with debt problems since 1989, including sequestration and insolvency. Our debt experts can guide you through the process and help determine the best options. Please contact one our team members to arrange a free same-day consultation at any of our four offices in Scotland, or a location of your choice.
Your personal credit score plays an important part in securing new loans and credit, and can affect your financial life for better or worse. Lenders use the information in your credit file to determine whether you present a high risk of default, and if your credit score is low, you may find it difficult to […]
Credit unions offer a range of financial products including current accounts, savings accounts, and loans, and can be a good alternative to banks and building societies whilst also helping your cash flow. There are credit unions all around the UK, almost 100 of them operating in Scotland. They’re not always widely advertised, however, and although […]
It’s a worrying situation when you realise your outgoings exceed your income, and it can be difficult to prevent debt in this situation, but there are solid steps you can take to get back on track – you just need to act quickly. Increasing your income or reducing the money going out are essentially what […]
If you’ve lost your job, state benefits and tax credits can provide vital financial support to see you through this tough time and help you avoid taking on too much debt while you look for more work. As far as your old employment is concerned, it’s important that you check your final wage slip to […]
A Debt Arrangement Scheme (DAS) is a government backed scheme which allows you to repay debt through contractual, monthly instalments without the threat of legal action and incurring penalties or interest. The scheme was established in 2004 for Scottish residents in debt, providing an alternative solution to sequestration, the Scottish equivalent of bankruptcy. A Debt […]